Loaded Pimento Baby Potatoes

Recipe Note

Recipe FAQ

Why boil the potatoes before baking rather than just baking them from raw?

Boiling guarantees the interior is fully tender and creamy before the potato ever hits the oven — something you can't reliably achieve with raw potatoes at 400°F in 15–20 minutes without the exterior drying out first. The bake phase is about browning the tops, melting the fats into the fluffed interior, and adding wood-fired character, not about cooking the potato through. This two-step method gives you the best of both: a cooked-through, fluffy center and a lightly crisped, browned top with melted cheese.

Why fork-fluff the interior after splitting rather than just loading it flat?

The fork-fluffing step creates nooks and surface area inside the potato that butter and pimento cheese can melt into rather than sitting on top of. A flat, unfluffed potato surface is smooth and dense — the fats pool on top and run off rather than absorbing into the flesh. Roughing the interior up creates a texture closer to a baked potato interior, which holds the butter and melted cheese and integrates them into every bite rather than leaving them as a separate layer on top.

What kind of pimento cheese works best, and should it go in cold or room temperature?

A sharp cheddar-based pimento cheese spread works best — the sharpness cuts through the richness of the butter and holds its flavor presence after melting. Add it cold directly from the fridge. Cold pimento cheese holds its shape as a distinct dollop going into the oven and melts slowly and evenly as the potato heats through, producing a smooth, cohesive melt rather than immediately running off a warm surface. Room temperature cheese spreads too fast before the potato has fully heated.

Why cook the bacon on a wire rack over a sheet pan rather than directly on the pan?

The rack lifts the bacon off the pan surface so fat drains away rather than pooling underneath — bacon sitting in its own rendered fat fries on the bottom while the top steams, producing uneven texture. On the rack, heat circulates around the entire slice, the fat drips cleanly below, and every strip renders and crisps evenly. Save the drippings in the pan: spooning that flavored bacon fat back over the potatoes before serving is one of the best finishing moves in this recipe.

Can I cook this Indoors?

We rate this a 4 out of 5 for cooking indoors. Great in the kitchen, better on the grill. The boiling step is fully stovetop, and a conventional oven at 400°F handles the baking phase well — finish with a 1–2 minute broil for extra browning if needed. What you give up is the hickory backdrop and the slightly more intense, concentrated radiant heat of the wood-fired oven, which produces a particularly crisp cheese top.

Recipe Highlights & Insights

• The Hardcore Carnivore Amplify seasoning applied before baking is doing more than basic salt work here. Amplify is a glutamate-heavy, intensely savory seasoning — essentially MSG-forward flavor enhancement — that makes the butter, pimento cheese, and potato all taste more deeply of themselves without adding a distinct seasoning flavor. Applied lightly before the cheese goes on, it amplifies the dairy richness without competing with it. It's the reason the finished potato tastes fuller and more complex than the ingredient list suggests.

   

• Spooning the rendered butter and bacon fat back over the potatoes from the sheet pan before finishing is the detail that separates good loaded potatoes from great ones. That pooled fat on the pan has the flavor of everything that cooked into it — seasoned butter, pimento cheese drippings, duck fat spray — and reapplying it basts the potato tops with the most concentrated version of the recipe's flavor profile. Don't pour it off or discard it; use it.

   

• Baby gold (Yukon-style) potatoes are the right choice specifically because of their size and skin character. At 1.5 lb for 12 potatoes, each one is a true two-bite portion — large enough to hold filling and toppings, small enough to eat without cutting. Their thin, tender skin crisps lightly in the oven rather than going leathery, and their waxy-creamy flesh holds its shape when fork-fluffed without turning mealy. Russet-style potatoes would be mealy; red potatoes would be denser and less fluffy.

   

• This recipe scales exactly and linearly — every component is measured per potato (1 tsp butter, 1 tsp pimento cheese) so doubling or tripling for a larger gathering requires no recalculation. The boil-and-hold method also means potatoes can be prepped hours in advance, then filled and baked in two rounds if needed for a buffet. They hold well on the pan for up to 30 minutes of service, which makes them one of the most practical high-volume sides in the ATBBQ catalog.

Recommended Recipes

• Whipped Brie & Bacon Toast

• Cuban Croquetas

• Croissant Toast Points

• Chicken Tortilla Soup