Recipe Note
Recipe FAQ
Should I use pickled or fresh cherry peppers?
Pickled cherry peppers are strongly recommended. The pickling brine adds a tangy acidity that cuts through the richness of the cream cheese and bacon, producing a more balanced bite. Fresh cherry peppers work but deliver only heat without the tang — the result is heavier and less complex. The pickled version is also more widely available year-round.
What does the 8 Second Ride Carne Asada Seasoning add?
The seasoning adds a layer of savory, slightly smoky depth to the cream cheese filling that plain cream cheese can't provide on its own. Its chile and garlic notes complement both the tangy pepper and the salty bacon without competing with either. A light sprinkle on the filling before wrapping, and an optional second sprinkle on the bacon exterior, is all that's needed.
How do I keep the bacon from unraveling on the grill?
Use thin-cut bacon — it wraps more conformably around the curved pepper half and adheres better than thick-cut. Secure with a toothpick if needed, especially if the pepper halves are large. Place the peppers seam-side down on the grill first; the direct heat sets the bacon wrap before the first turn.
How long do these take on the grill?
Approximately 15–20 minutes total at 350°F. Place seam-side down for 8–10 minutes until the bacon is set and beginning to crisp, then turn and cook another 6–8 minutes until the bacon is fully rendered and crispy on all sides. The cream cheese filling will be warm and slightly softened when done — this is correct and expected.
Can I prepare these ahead of time?
Yes — assemble the filled, wrapped peppers up to 24 hours in advance and refrigerate covered until ready to grill. Cold peppers going onto a 350°F grill will need an extra 3–5 minutes cook time to ensure the cream cheese warms through. They can also be assembled and frozen for up to 1 month; thaw fully in the refrigerator before grilling.
Can I make these indoors?
4 out of 5 — Great in the kitchen, better on the grill. A 350°F oven produces near-identical results — place on a wire rack over a foil-lined sheet pan so rendered bacon fat drips away rather than pooling. The bacon will crisp evenly and the cream cheese will soften the same way. What you lose is the faint live-fire char on the bacon exterior — minor for this recipe.
Recipe Highlights
Pat the peppers completely dry before filling: Directions Step 4 specifies patting the halved, seeded peppers dry with paper towel. Pickled peppers retain significant moisture in their cavities — wet pepper interiors cause the cream cheese to slide out during filling and prevent the bacon from crisping properly where it contacts the pepper surface. Dry peppers hold the filling cleanly and produce crispier bacon contact points.
Use cream cheese spread, not block cream cheese: The recipe specifies cream cheese spread (the softer, whipped variety in tubs) rather than standard block cream cheese. Spread-style cream cheese is already softened and pipes or scoops into the pepper cavity cleanly at refrigerator temperature. Block cream cheese needs to be brought to room temperature and softened before use, or it will tear the pepper rather than filling it smoothly.
Cut each bacon slice in half before wrapping: Directions Step 1 of the bacon wrap section specifies cutting each slice in half. A full bacon slice is too long to wrap a small pepper half neatly — it overlaps multiple times and creates thick, unevenly cooked layers. A half slice wraps once around the pepper with just enough overlap to secure, producing even crisping across the entire surface.
Season the bacon exterior as well as the cream cheese filling: Directions Step 4 of the wrap section notes the option to season the bacon-wrapped exterior with additional Carne Asada. Seasoning the outside of the bacon creates a spiced crust as it renders on the grill — the seasoning blooms in the rendered fat and produces a more complex exterior than unseasoned bacon alone.
Recommended Recipes
