Stabilize your Kettle Joe Grill at 450° F. Bank all of your charcoal to the back of the grill.
Set one Grill Grate at the lowest setting for direct cooking and set 1 Deflector Shield on the other side with a Grill Grate above it on the highest setting for semi-indirect cooking.
While the grill is coming to temperature, form 2, 4 oz paddies for each burger. Top the bottom paddy of each burger with 2 slices of American cheese. Place the second paddies on top of the cheese and crimp the edges so that the cheese cannot escape as the burger cooks and the cheese melts.
Draw an oiled paper towel across the Grill Grates to create a non-stick surface. Season the burgers with R Butts R Smokin’ R Beef BBQ Rub and place them on the direct side of the grill. Cook for 1 and a half minutes then rotate 90° and cook for another minute. Flip and repeat. The dome should be closed during the searing process.
Transfer the seared burgers and burger buns to the indirect side. Close the dome for 2 minutes.
Transfer the bottom bun to a cutting board. Top with sauce, lettuce, tomato, sliced pickles, Juicy Lucy patties, and lastly the top bun that has been sauced. Enjoy but proceed with caution. That lava cheese can burn your mouth. That’s why this burger is known as the burger that bites back!